Intriguing Forgotten NFT Projects: The Hype, the Bust, and the Lessons Learned in 2024

Intriguing Forgotten NFT Projects: The Hype, the Bust, and the Lessons Learned in 2024

May 7, 2024 by Diana Ambolis
The NFT (Non-Fungible Token) market has exploded in popularity, attracting both ardent believers and harsh critics. While success stories abound, the space is littered with projects that fizzled out, leaving disappointed investors and unanswered questions. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of failed NFT projects, exploring the common pitfalls and helping you navigate the NFT landscape with
NFT Projects Bitcoin Side Projects

The NFT (Non-Fungible Token) market has exploded in popularity, attracting both ardent believers and harsh critics. While success stories abound, the space is littered with projects that fizzled out, leaving disappointed investors and unanswered questions. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of failed NFT projects, exploring the common pitfalls and helping you navigate the NFT landscape with caution:

Understanding Failure: A Multifaceted Abyss

NFT projects failures can stem from various factors, often a toxic cocktail of several issues:

  • Lack of Utility and Value Proposition: Many projects offer nothing more than generic artwork with no real-world use case or clear path to future value creation. Imagine buying a digital image of a pixelated cat with no unique perks or functionality. What’s the incentive to hold onto it?

  • Hype-Driven Marketing and Empty Promises: Promises of “exclusive communities,” “lucrative future benefits,” or celebrity endorsements can create a frenzy, but fail to deliver on substance. Think “pump and dump” schemes, but with digital art.

  • Poor Execution and Unrealistic Roadmaps: Ambitious roadmaps outlining game-changing metaverse integration or groundbreaking utility features often fall flat due to a lack of technical expertise or a complete misunderstanding of the resources required. Think building a digital city on the moon with a team of two people.

  • Community Mismanagement and Broken Trust: Failing to foster a positive and engaged community around the project is a recipe for disaster. Imagine the NFT projects creators disappearing after launch, leaving investors high and dry.

  • Rug Pulls: The Ultimate Betrayal: In the most malicious scenario, developers create a project, hype it up, and then abruptly abandon it after taking all the invested funds. This is essentially a digital heist in the NFT world.

Red Flags to Watch Out For: Imposter Syndrome in the NFT Arena

While predicting success is difficult, here are some red flags to be wary of:

  • Generic artwork with no unique features: If the NFTs look like something you could easily create yourself, there’s probably not much value proposition.

  • Unrealistic promises and a lack of concrete details: Be wary of NFT projects that make grand pronouncements without a clear roadmap or explanation of how they’ll achieve their goals.

  • Unexperienced development team: Research the team behind the NFT projects. Do they have a proven track record in technology or the creative field relevant to the NFT?

  • Sudden surges in hype with no clear catalyst: Be skeptical of NFT projects that experience a meteoric rise in popularity without any significant news or development updates.

  • Overly aggressive marketing tactics: If the marketing feels like it’s pressuring you to buy in immediately, take a step back and do your own research.

Also, read – Top 10 Most Popular NFT Projects Of 2023 That Made Headlines

Top 10 Failed and Forgotten NFT Projects: A Graveyard of Lost Hype

The NFT landscape is littered with the remains of once-hyped projects that promised the moon and delivered… well, a whole lot of nothing. Here’s a closer look at 10 such failures, along with the cautionary tales they offer:

1. Frosties: The Meltdown of a Cool Concept

  • Promise: Frosties offered a delightful concept – adorable, unique ice cream-themed NFTs with a roadmap promising exclusive access and community events.
  • Reality: After a successful launch, raking in millions, the developers vanished like a scoop left out in the sun. Investors were left holding the digital cone, with nothing but a bad taste in their mouth (pun intended).
  • Lesson: Be wary of NFT projects with anonymous teams or unrealistic promises. A delicious concept doesn’t guarantee a successful project.

2. Evolved Apes: Stagnation in the Jungle

  • Promise: Evolved Apes promised a dynamic experience – apes that would visually evolve over time, adding value and excitement.
  • Reality: The promised evolution never materialized. The apes remained stubbornly static, mirroring the investors’ bank accounts.
  • Lesson: Scrutinize project roadmaps. Don’t be swayed by visuals alone. Are there clear, achievable development plans with a realistic timeline?

3. Lootmart: Mystery Boxes of Disappointment

  • Promise: Lootmart offered a chance to snag valuable NFTs through “mystery boxes.” These boxes were touted as containing a range of exciting digital treasures.
  • Reality: Most boxes contained generic, low-quality items. The promised “treasures” were more like consolation prizes from a carnival claw machine.
  • Lesson: Mystery boxes often mask a lack of true value. Look for NFT projects with transparent offerings and a clear understanding of what you’re buying.

4. CryptoKitties: The Fall of the Feline Founding Fathers

  • Promise: CryptoKitties were among the first NFT projects, sparking a global craze. They promised a unique breeding system and a vibrant digital cat community.
  • Reality: While initially successful, CryptoKitties struggled to maintain excitement. Breeding mechanics became monotonous, and the community dwindled.
  • Lesson: Even pioneers can falter. The NFT space evolves rapidly. NFT Projects need to adapt and innovate to stay relevant.

5. CryptoPunks: A Pyrrhic Victory?

  • Promise: CryptoPunks were another early adopter project, offering a collection of pixelated characters with varying degrees of rarity.
  • Reality: CryptoPunks have achieved cult status and astronomical prices for the rarest ones. However, a large portion of the collection remains relatively worthless, highlighting the extreme disparity in value within some NFT projects.
  • Lesson: Rarity doesn’t guarantee success for every NFT. Consider the overall project concept and utility, not just the potential for a lucky windfall.

6. Moments by Dapper Labs: The Fading Buzz of Sports Moments

  • Promise: Moments offered a chance to own officially licensed digital collectibles featuring iconic sports highlights.
  • Reality: The initial hype waned as the novelty wore off. Liquidity issues plagued the marketplace, making it difficult to buy or sell these digital moments.
  • Lesson: Official licensing doesn’t guarantee success. Look for NFT projects that offer unique utility beyond just owning a digital highlight reel.

7. NBA Top Shot: The All-Star Slump

  • Promise: Similar to Moments, NBA Top Shot offered a chance to own officially licensed video clips of iconic NBA plays.
  • Reality: While initially popular, the market became saturated with digital highlight reels, leading to a drop in demand and value.
  • Lesson: Scarcity and exclusivity are crucial for NFTs. A flooded marketplace can erode value for early investors.

8. Fidenza by Tyler Hobbs: Algorithmic Art’s Rocky Terrain

  • Promise: Fidenza offered algorithmically generated art by a respected artist, promising a unique and ever-evolving collection.
  • Reality: The algorithmic generation led to a sense of homogeneity in the artwork. Additionally, the high initial price point deterred many potential collectors.
  • Lesson: Not all art translates well to the NFT format. Consider the appeal of the artwork itself beyond the novelty of it being an NFT.

9. Bored Ape Yacht Club: The Highs and Lows of Exclusivity (Continued)

  • Critics argue: The project has been accused of being exclusionary and catering to an elite group, with the high cost of entry creating a barrier for many potential investors. Additionally, concerns have been raised about the long-term sustainability of the project’s value proposition.
  • Lesson: Exclusivity can be a double-edged sword. While it may attract a premium initially, it can also alienate potential investors and hinder long-term growth.

10. Pixelmon: When the Pixels Don’t Pop

  • Promise: Pixelmon promised a monster-catching game similar to Pokemon, built entirely on the blockchain with unique NFT creatures.
  • Reality: The project was plagued by delays and technical issues. The promised gameplay never materialized, leaving investors with nothing but pixelated disappointment.
  • Lesson: Be wary of NFT projects with ambitious roadmaps and complex technical requirements. Building a robust and functional game on the blockchain is a significant undertaking.

These cautionary tales highlight the importance of thorough research before investing in any NFT project. Consider the project’s concept, team, roadmap, and overall utility. Don’t get swept up in the hype – focus on projects with a clear value proposition and a sustainable path to success. Remember, the NFT landscape is dynamic, and yesterday’s hot project can quickly become tomorrow’s forgotten relic. By staying informed and exercising caution, you can navigate this exciting yet challenging frontier with a greater chance of success.

Lessons for Investors and Creators: Learning from Failed NFT Projects

The fallen NFT projects we explored offer valuable lessons for both investors and creators in this evolving space. Here’s a breakdown of key takeaways:

For Investors:

  • Do Your Own Research (DYOR): Don’t blindly follow the hype. Research the project’s concept, team, roadmap, and the artwork itself.
  • Focus on Utility and Value: Look beyond the digital art. Does the project offer real-world use cases, unique experiences, or a strong community element?
  • Invest What You Can Afford to Lose: The NFT market is volatile. Invest only what you’re comfortable potentially losing entirely.
  • Beware of Red Flags: Watch out for generic artwork, unrealistic promises, anonymous teams, and overly aggressive marketing tactics.
  • Understand the Risks and Rewards: Be aware of the potential for scams, rug pulls, and sudden drops in value.

For Creators:

  • Focus on Building Value: Don’t just create generic art. Offer unique experiences, utility, or a strong community focus.
  • Have a Clear Roadmap: Outline your project’s development plan with achievable milestones and a realistic timeline.
  • Be Transparent: Build trust with your community by being transparent about your team, goals, and potential challenges.
  • Don’t Overpromise: Underpromise and overdeliver. Avoid making unrealistic claims that you can’t support.
  • Adapt and Innovate: The NFT space moves quickly. Be prepared to adapt your project and embrace innovation to stay relevant.

Additional Considerations:

  • Community Building: A strong and engaged community is crucial for any NFT project’s success. Foster positive interactions and listen to your community’s feedback.
  • Sustainability: Consider the long-term viability of your project. How will you maintain value and engagement over time?
  • Legal and Regulatory Landscape: Stay informed about evolving legal and regulatory considerations surrounding NFTs.

By understanding the pitfalls of failed NFT projects and applying these lessons, both investors and creators can increase their chances of success in the ever-evolving NFT landscape. Remember, a healthy dose of skepticism, coupled with a focus on value and community, can be your guiding light in this exciting yet challenging new frontier.


The year 2024 paints a fascinating picture of the NFT landscape. Once-hyped NFT projects, emblazoned across social media and touted as revolutionary, now gather dust in the forgotten corners of the internet. Their rapid rise and fall offer valuable cautionary tales for investors and creators alike.

These fallen NFT projects, like Fidenza’s algorithmic art that promised endless evolution yet delivered monotony, or Pixelmon’s ambitious blockchain-based monster game that fizzled out before launch, serve as stark reminders of the perils of unchecked hype. Investors, caught in the whirlwind of excitement, poured money into NFT projects with flimsy foundations – generic artwork, unrealistic roadmaps, and anonymous teams. The allure of overnight riches or exclusive communities proved too strong for some, leading to a frenzy of buying without proper due diligence.

However, the story doesn’t end there. From the ashes of these forgotten NFT projects rise valuable lessons that can guide both investors and creators navigating the ever-evolving NFT space. Investors now understand the importance of meticulous research. They delve deeper, scrutinizing the project’s concept, the team’s experience, and the roadmap’s feasibility. Gone are the days of blind faith in flashy marketing campaigns; a healthy dose of skepticism reigns supreme.

Creators, too, have learned from these cautionary tales. They understand the need to move beyond generic artwork and build NFT projects with genuine utility. Strong communities are nurtured, fostering a sense of shared purpose and collaboration. Transparency becomes paramount, with clear roadmaps and open communication building trust with potential investors. Sustainability takes center stage, with creators crafting projects with a long-term vision, ensuring their viability beyond the initial hype cycle.

The forgotten NFT projects of 2024 serve as a testament to the dynamic nature of this nascent technology. The space is not immune to bubbles and bursts, fueled by speculation and unrealistic expectations. Yet, amidst the wreckage, a silver lining emerges – a more informed and discerning group of investors and creators. The focus has shifted from fleeting hype to long-term value proposition, fostering a more sustainable and promising future for NFTs.

The forgotten NFT projects may fade from the spotlight, but the lessons they impart continue to resonate. As the NFT landscape continues to evolve, these lessons will serve as guiding principles, ensuring that future NFT projects are built on a foundation of value, community, and innovation, not just fleeting hype. The saga of forgotten NFTs is not a story of failure, but rather a cautionary tale that paves the way for a more discerning and prosperous future in the exciting world of digital assets.